Results

Trending topics

Select your station

We'll remember your choice for next time

Ratings | Round 2 – Richmond v. Collingwood

2017-03-30T22:30+11:00

Richmond fought off a strong Collingwood challenge to record consecutive wins to start the 2017 season, with a 19-point victory at the MCG.

With skipper Trent Cotchin leading by example, and Dustin Martin proving a handful in attack, the Tigers finished with a flurry despite three finl-term goals from Magpie recruit Will Hoskin-Elliott.

Our Inside Football experts take a look at the individual performances of each player...

RICHMOND – 14.15 (99)

David ASTBURY – 4

Took White and had a generally hard night chasing the in-form Magpie. Stuck to his guns.

Dan BUTLER – 3

Eight disposals and a goal, the odd good moment, but things didn’t fall his way quite as they did in Round 1.

Josh CADDY – 5

Played forward a fair bit where he was a presence but managed only one goal. Fair night at the office.

Jason CASTAGNA – 3

Pressure forward bobbed up occasionally but didn’t trouble the scoreboard attendant.

Reece CONCA – 6

Steady game (18 disposals) and stood his strong body under some high balls in defence.

Trent COTCHIN – 8

Tigers’ leading disposal winner (26) and topped hard-edged game with two goals. Last 10 minutes superb.

Shane EDWARDS – 6

Created problems early up forward despite misses; sharked a well-read goal at a stoppage and made a crucial third-quarter intercept.

Brandon ELLIS – 5

Freak snapshot in third term to trigger a momentum swing. Otherwise quiet off a wing.

Ben GRIFFITHS – 2

Speccy in second term but head hit ground after a similar attempt in third. Pretty much summed up his night.

Shaun GRIGG – 5

Unusually unproductive until managed some crucial touches including lovely goal in final term.

Dylan GRIMES – 4

On Fasolo and although barely touched the ball probably took the honours due to the Magpie’s shocking finishing.

Bachar HOULI – 6

Slow start but wound up having a good night charging off half back; even managed a goal pushing forward late.

Kane LAMBERT – 3

Came off the bench to get involved with a dozen disposals forward of centre. Will it be enough to hold his place?

Ben LENNON – 5

Only six kicks and three tackles but seemed more involved than that. Lively at half forward.

Dustin MARTIN – 7

Wearing a shiner after early head clash. Kept in check but his possessions were telling and two late goals buried the Pies.

Toby NANKERVIS – 7

Gave Grundy something to think about, especially with his marking around ground. Tigers have a good one here.

Dion PRESTIA – 5

Puts himself in all the right places, although he often kicked under pressure and missed targets.

Alex RANCE – 6

Good duel with Moore, who he found slippery, but still a strong contributor.

Jack RIEWOLDT – 5

Thrown into the midfield after invisible first half which got him going. Two goals were important to the comeback.

Daniel RIOLI – 5

Worked hard between the 50-metre lines. Pace was a factor – this guy is becoming a player.

Jayden SHORT – 6

Returned in the back pocket, picked up Broomhead and won the contest after conceding some early touches.

Nick VLASTUIN – 5

Lined up on Mayne and had the edge. Went hard at every contest from half back.


COLLINGWOOD – 11.14 (80)

Taylor ADAMS – 7

Combative, bullocking game; suited by the scrappy contest. Eight tackles an indication of his work-rate.

James AISH – 2

Returned on a wing but still looks (and plays) like a first-year player. Lacks penetration in his play.

Jarryd BLAIR – 1

Totally ineffective for the second week running. Give Daicos a game.

Tim BROOMHEAD – 4

Lively opening (first goal) and did enough to persevere with. Been in the system long enough to be making his mark.

Jack CRISP – 3

Struggling for clean possession and often looks as though he miskicks the ball.

Alex FASOLO – 3

Has replaced Cloke as the momentum drainer in the Magpie attack: 0.6 from set shots this season.

Tyson GOLDSACK – 6

Blanketed Riewoldt in the first half but found the going much harder thereafter.

Brodie GRUNDY – 7

Hands full with Nankervis but got on top as the game wore on. Fine running goal in third term

Will HOSKIN-ELLIOTT – 6

Showed a touch of class and three goals from half forward kept the Pies in it.

Jeremy HOWE – 8

His proprioception (look it up) is the best in the league. In All-Australian nick as a defender with the lot.

Brayden MAYNARD – 4

On Lennon and lowered his colours. Still giving away rookie free kicks (including a late one that cost a crucial goal).

Chris MAYNE – 3

One nice goal on half time but missed sitter after a great tackle soon after. Not enough from the half million-dollar man.

Darcy MOORE – 5

A bit nippy for Rance and won the ball on the lead, but made only one of three gettable shots.

Scott PENDLEBURY – 8

Usual proportion of deft touches among 32 disposals; almost dragged his teammates over the line with a superb final term.

Tom PHILLIPS – 5

Picked up Edwards, who gave him grief early, but fought well and often in the chain running it out of defence.

Jackson RAMSAY – 2

Lively if a bit fumbly and only three kicks to his name out of a back pocket. Wouldn’t be happy with his game.

Ben REID – 7

Controlled the air at centre half back. Tiger forwards were reduced to taking improbable flies to counter he and Howe.

Henry SCHADE – 6

No job too difficult is his motto. Left foot is safe and he gets far more involved in attack than his departed predecessor Brown.

Steele SIDEBOTTOM – 4

Started brightly, as he so often does, but became a non-factor. Only eight kicks not enough from his wing.

Josh SMITH – 6

Better than opening round at half back. Won the ball well and his right boot is very safe (16 kicks from 19 disposals).

Adam TRELOAR – 8

Proving well worth the two first-round picks the Pies sacrificed (and he’s all paid up now); 35 disposals and two fine goals.

Jesse WHITE – 7

Again the Pies’ best forward. Suddenly showing footy smarts (apart from a late bump) to go with his athleticism.

Inside Football AFL Player Ratings Collingwood Richmond

More in AFL

Featured