Results

Trending topics

Select your station

We'll remember your choice for next time

Ratings | Round 3 – Sydney v. Collingwood

2017-04-07T22:30+10:00

Collingwood recorded a stirring one-point win over Sydney at the SCG, relieving pressure on coach Nathan Buckley.

Our Inside Football experts take a look at the individual performances of each player...

SYDNEY SWANS – 11.13 (79)

Aliir ALIIR – 6

After sluggish start he got going. Dare and guile from defence is a real thing of beauty. Just backs himself.

Jordan DAWSON – 2

Youngster was only a very minor player in the overall effort. Only six effective disposals playing forward.

Oliver FLORENT – 3

Only kick in first term resulted in a goal and he kicked one himself in final term to cut margin to one point late in match.

Jordan FOOTE – 3

Youngster found the going tough. Eight effective disposals but laid six tackles so effort was there.

Robbie FOX – 4

Jagged sides first goal 18 minutes into first term and showed glimpses throughout. Certainly plenty to work with.

Lance FRANKLIN – 4

250th game celebration turned sour. Failed to kick a goal for only fourth time in past 38 matches. Gave a few away.

Heath GRUNDY – 7

Job on Moore and did the superbly well. Among the better Swans on the night.

Dan HANNEBERY – 7

Better night for the star Swan. Still not at brutal best but nine tackles, and six clearances indicates high work-rate.

Will HAYWARD – 6

Not sighted in first term then came to life to kick two second-term goals and another in last. Made most of his six kicks.

George HEWETT – 4

Zero influence on the flow of the game early then got better. Like many teammates lacked four-quarter presence.

Kieren JACK – 4

Slow start but then jagged two second-time goals to get side back into game. Still well short of his hard-running best.

Zak JONES – 7

Battled manfully in defence and around the ball all night to be a fine contributor for his team.

Josh KENNEDY – 7

Midfield bull grabbed a lot of ball (33 disposals) but just 18 effective. Seven clearances and a goal to be a factor.

Jake LLOYD – 6

Again at the pointy end of team’s top disposal winners with 33. Impact given number is questionable. One inside-50.

Harry MARSH – 6

Under siege down back but held up pretty well given Magpie tackle pressure. Steady start to the year continues.

Callum MILLS – 6

Star youngster does his work with the minimum of fuss. Has played better games but still offered something from the back half.

Sam NAISMITH – 2

Big ruckman not as good as previous weeks and well beaten on the night by Grundy. Seven hit-outs to advantage.

Nic NEWMAN – 7

Fine effort given his inexperience. Snapped up 23 disposals, four tackles and kicked a gaol to be among better performers.

Luke PARKER – 5

Stud playmaker isn’t at the level to which he’s accustomed. Worked hard but just 13 effective disposals and one inside-50.

Sam REID – 1

Ball never got to him in first term. First disposal came at 12-minute mark of second term and well beaten by his brother Ben.

Nick SMITH – 3

All sorts of issues with Fasalo who booted three first-term goals and four before halftime. Got on top after that, but still struggling.


COLLINGWOOD – 11.14 (80)

Taylor ADAMS – 8

Set the tone with his defensive work in close laying a truckload of tackles (11). Spent time at half back too.

Tim BROOMHEAD – 6

Missed a few chances on the night, but got his hands on the ball well and did his bit.

Jack CRISP – 6

Rotated through midfield and was given a few different roles, but played his part when required.

Alex FASOLO – 7

On fire with a four-goal first half but then cooled off. Missed one late, but in the end, his opening barrage was huge.

Tyson GOLDSACK – 6

Good down back against the resting ruckman for large parts. Not big numbers, but played his part.

Levi GREENWOOD – 6

Battled away in midfield and could have made Swans’ pay more on scoreboard, but missed chances. Fair.

Brodie GRUNDY – 7

Superb in opening half opposed to Naismith, mostly in ruck. Steady second half but had good moments late.

Will HOSKIN-ELLIOTT – 7

Excellent start and kicked a monster goal in the final term that proved to be the difference. Took 10 marks.

Jeremy HOWE – 7

Cut off Sydney attacks well after half time. Picks the right time to sag off opponent and impact the contest.

Brayden MAYNARD – 6

Some key touches late and showed composure with ball in hand but also had his hands full defensively at stages.

Chris MAYNE – 4

Quiet offensively but did his bit defensively at times in front half. Needs to do more.

Darcy MOORE – 3

Okay early, but then a spectator for long periods again – it’s becoming a worrying pattern. Winnings helps though.

Scott PENDLEBURY – 7

Despite Magpies strong start, was quieter than normal, but then played a pivotal in second half role in what was a famous win.

Tom PHILLIPS – 8

Ball magnet early with 19 first-half touches, and ended with 27. Always available to provide a link in midfield.

Jackson RAMSAY – 6

Had some worrying moments, but overall stood steadily enough to help keep Swans at bay.

Ben REID – 8

Great duel with his brother in defence and took the points comfortably for much of the night. 10 marks.

Henry SCHADE – 8

Humungous task on Buddy in his 250th. In his wildest dreams, he wouldn’t have thought he could keep him goalless. He did.

Steele SIDEBOTTOM – 8

Laid 12 tackles, which isn’t his normal gig, but composure under pressure with ball in hand was important at key times.

Josh SMITH – 6

Stood tall in a few key moments and distributed the ball fairly well across the night.

Adam TRELOAR – 7

Superb third-quarter goal and got his hands dirty with a remarkable 14 tackles. Exemplified the Pies’ blue-collar approach.

Travis VARCOE – 5

Back from suspension and took a while to get rolling, but second half touches were important in the overall scheme of things.

Jesse WHITE – 6

Cracking long goal in second term against old mob and continued to work hard.

Inside Football AFL Player Ratings Sydney Swans Collingwood

More in AFL

Featured