Results

Trending topics

Select your station

We'll remember your choice for next time

Ratings | Round 6 – Geelong v. Collingwood

2017-04-30T18:15+10:00

A Scott Pendlebury-led Collingwood ended Geelong's unbeaten start to the season with an inspired 29-point win at the MCG.

Our Inside Football experts take a look at the individual performances of each player...

GEELONG – 11.12 (78)

Jed BEWS – 6

First game for the season. Had Fasolo and from that perspective did well given one of Pies’ goals came when he was off ground.

Aaron BLACK – 2

Good form lasted just the one week. Seven effective disposals and no goals. Does he return to the VFL?

Mark BLICAVS – 2

Another poor day in the middle. At some point coaching staff will work out he can’t play midfield to save himself; nine effective disposals.

Nakia COCKATOO – 2

First goal of game then couldn’t get into the contest at all. Tried to be physical with a few Pies but it backfired.

Patrick DANGERFIELD – 4

Quiet by his standards in first half (eight effective disposals) and even less in second. Ribs a concern, as he was way off?

Mitch DUNCAN – 7

In terms of sheer possession numbers he was best of Cats’ onballers; 27 disposals, seven inside-50s and a goal.

Cameron GUTHRIE – 5

Plugged away rotating half/back midfield but in the end his effort didn’t amount to a whole lot.

Tom HAWKINS – 2

One goal in first half only influence. Timing of his leap for marks was well off. Well beaten by Dunn.

Lachie HENDERSON – 6

Had job on Moore who caused him some issues, particularly in the first half. Battled hard and certainly not the worst.

George HORLIN-SMITH – 5

Quiet first half (9 disposals) then tried to lift but impact not commensurate. Did lay team-high nine tackles so effort solid.

Darcy LANG – 3

Mixed good and bad. Sometimes looks assured other times he plays VFL footy and pays the price.

Tom LONERGAN – 5

Got the job on big Yank Cox and handy enough. Under siege at times and lots of his touches were cheapies out the back.

Andrew MACKIE – 7

Took Elliott and given scoreboard actually did a reasonable job. Grabbed plenty of the ball himself to end among the best.

Sam MENEGOLA – 3

First half horrible. If weight of possessions is your benchmark he was okay. On naked eye scale he offered little.

Steven MOTLOP – 3

One great goals only highlight of an error-filled performance ion which his inability to make correct decisions is diabolical.

Jordan MURDOCH – 5

One of few Cats to look steady, particularly in the first half. Effort faded as game dragged on; 17 disposals.

Brandan PARFITT – 4

Kid showed his class when he got the ball. One nice goal then hamstring flew out of his leg in final term.

Joel SELWOOD – 3

After 43 possessions last week was held to 17 by Greenwood who wore him cheap suit style from start to finish. Unusual quiet one.

Zac SMITH – 1

Didn’t have a kick in the first half. Tried to lift in third term but had zero influence on the flow of the game. Didn’t take a mark.

Tom STEWART – 5

Defended pretty well for inexperienced player. Modest in terms of rebound but good experience for the mature-aged recruit.

Harry TAYLOR – 4

Couple of nice marks but just looks like a different player when he returns to defence. One goal in first term.

Zach TUOHY – 8

Close to Cats’ best again. Rebounded well and defended stoutly when he had to; 36 disposals and non-stop running.


COLLINGWOOD – 15.17 (107)

Taylor ADAMS – 8

Ran hard and despite a bevy of errant disposals he won enough of it to be a huge driving force in the middle.

Tim BROOMHEAD – 4

Flitted in and out for one goal and a couple of inside-50s. Played small part in the win without going overboard.

Mason COX – 4

Big man provided a target both forward and in the ruck. Got a great capacity to drop a mark.

Jack CRISP – 7

Got under guard of Cats to grab 25 disposals. Importantly 21 of them hit the target given efficiency is his issue.

Lynden DUNN – 8

Had to man the bigger Hawkins and did a wonderful job to keep the big Cat to one goal and five kicks.

Jamie ELLIOTT – 4

Great battle against Mackie. Ended with one goal from five kicks in a quiet sort of day.

Alex FASOLO – 4

One kick in first half and six for the match. Two goals but for the most part wasn’t a huge factor.

Tyson GOLDSACK – 5

Defensively had Cockatoo covered and that was the key to his role. Only six kicks but did what was required.

Levi GREENWOOD – 8

Tagged Selwood and had him covered in what was a huge win for the side given the skipper’s importance.

Brodie GRUNDY – 6

Dominated ruck and was far superior to Smith who couldn’t get warm. Early in game set up clearance domination.

Will HOSKIN-ELLIOTT – 8

Relished space afforded to him by Cats in first half (12 disposals) and backed up with another 14 after main break. One goal.

Jeremy HOWE – 6

Didn’t take a hanger which was slightly disappointing for fans. Did his job from half back without starring.

Brayden MAYNARD – 3

Not sighted in terms of offensive input. Didn’t matter as others took control of the game.

Darcy MOORE – 6

Played best first half of year (10 disposals, two goals) and while effort faded his influence early was important.

Scott PENDLEBURY – 8

Skipper rose to the challenge yet again against Cats to grab 33 disposal, six inside-50s, nine tackles and a goal.

Tom PHILLIPS – 5

Good early then drifted out of the contest to a degree. Highlight was a goal and five inside-50s to help keep wheels turning.

Henry SCHADE – 5

Had job on Taylor and did reasonably well. Did get caught a few times in the back half but will learn from experience.

Steele SIDEBOTTOM – 6

Last time he played a bad game Harry Holt was still sizing up the surf. Just the 13 effective disposals but found space to use footy.

Josh SMITH – 8

Great start helped set the side in road to victory. Ball use was a highlight of his game given 23 of his 26 disposals hit the target.

Adam TRELOAR – 7

Five inside-50s, 26 disposals, five tackles and gut running kept the engine room ticking over. Solid effort.

Travis VARCOE – 5

Former Cat was causing some havoc until his hamstring went late in the third term; 14 disposals and rebound good.

Daniel WELLS – 6

Former Roo worked into game to be a factor. Used footy with precision and linked well off a wing.

Inside Football AFL Player Ratings Geelong Collingwood

More in AFL

Featured