Results

Trending topics

Select your station

We'll remember your choice for next time

Which clubs have the best and worst father-son strike rates?

2021-04-28T15:10+10:00

Father-son selections provide footy fans with large amounts of hope while also bring a little bit of romance to our great game.

Some sons of well-known fathers take to the competition like a duck to water whereas some find it difficult to live up the hype of their old man.

Clubs have more success the others when it comes to father-son selections while some clubs - naturally Gold Coast and GWS - are yet to even experience having the progeny of a past player come through the ranks.

But which club has the highest quantity of quality from their father-son picks?

According to data compiled by SEN’s Andy Maher, the Western Bulldogs head the success strike rate with five of the club’s eight father-sons receiving the tick of approval.

It places the Bulldogs ahead of renowned father-son club Geelong.

“You could argue that Geelong has had the best cluster of players taken,” Maher said on SEN’s Bob & Andy.

“It would be hard to go past Matthew Scarlett, Gary Ablett Junior and Tom Hawkins.

“They’ve had 13 father-sons in history and six of them, according to our data, have been ticks.

“The Western Bulldogs on the other hand have had eight father-sons, five of whom we have got as being ticks. That being Luke Darcy, Mitch Wallis, Tom Liberatore, Lachie Hunter and Zaine Cordy.

“That’s five passes at 62.5%.”

The top eight of father-son success was put together based on who the SEN Drive team feel have been ‘passes’ and/or ‘ticks’.

Father-son success top eight

Western Bulldogs: 62.5%
Geelong: 46.15%
Collingwood: 46.1%
Essendon: 42.8%
Sydney: 40%
Collingwood: 37.5%
West Coast 33.3%
Carlton: 30%

See all the father-son selections from each club below and specifically the ones that have been rated a TICK.

(Note: Some didn’t quite cut it at AFL level and some are too early to pass judgement on).

Adelaide club banner

0 of 2 at 0%

Ben Jarman (2016)
Jackson Edwards (2017)

Brisbane club banner

1 of 3 at 33.3%

Jonathan Brown (1999) - TICK
Shane Morrison (1999)
Josh Clayton (2014)

Carlton club banner

3 of 10 at 30%

Michael James (1988)
Chris Mulcair (1988)
Darren Walsh (1992)
David Walls (1995)
Lance Whitnall (1996) - TICK
Jarrad Waite (2001) - TICK
Luke Blackwell (2004)
Dylan Buckley (2011)
Jack Silvagni (2015) - TICK - (Still playing)
Ben Silvagni (2018)

Collingwood club banner

6 of 16 at 37.5%

Heath Shephard (1988)
Ernie Hug Jnr (1989)
Nick Davis (1998) - TICK
Brad Oborne (1998)
Rhyce Shaw (1999) - TICK
Jason Cloke (2000)
Cameron Cloke (2002)
Brayden Shaw (2003)
Heath Shaw (2003) - TICK
Travis Cloke (2004) - TICK
Jaxson Barham (2007)
Darcy Moore (2014) - TICK - (Still playing)
Callum Brown (2016) - (Still playing)
Josh Daicos (2016) - TICK - (Still playing)
Tyler Brown (2017) - (Still playing)
Will Kelly (2018) - (Still playing)

Essendon club banner

3 of 7 at 42.8%

Dustin Fletcher (1992) - TICK
Jobe Watson (2002) - TICK
Jay Neagle (2005)
Darcy Daniher (2007)
Joe Daniher (2012) - TICK
Jake Long (2015)
Tom Wallis (2016)

Fremantle club banner

0 of 1 at 0%

Brett Peake (2003)

Geelong club banner

6 of 13 at 46.15%

Simon Fletcher (1995)
Matthew Scarlett (1997) - TICK
Marc Woolnough (1997)
David Clarke (1998)
Gary Ablett Jnr (2001) - TICK
Tim Callan (2002)
Mark Blake (2003) - TICK
Nathan Ablett (2004) - TICK
Tom Hawkins (2006) - TICK - (Still playing)
Adam Donohue (2007)
Jed Bews (2011) - TICK - (Still playing)
Sam Simpson (2016) - (Still playing)
Oscar Brownless (2018) - (Still playing)

Gold Coast club banner

No father-son selections

GWS Giants club banner

No father-son selections

Hawthorn club banner

1 of 4 at 25%

Steven Greene (2000)
Travis Tuck (2005)
Josh Kennedy (2006) - TICK - (Still playing at Sydney)
Finn Maginness (2019) - (Still playing)

Melbourne club banner

1 of 6 at 16.6%

Tom Kavanagh (1988)
Bradley Campbell (1992)
Glenn Molloy (1992)
Chris Johnson (2003)
Jack Viney (2012) - TICK - (Still playing)
Billy Stretch (2014)

North Melbourne club banner

1 of 4 at 25%

Jesse Smith (2004)
Luke McDonald (2013) - TICK - (Still playing)
Joel Crocker (2018)
Bailey Scott (2018) - (Still playing)

Port Adelaide club banner

1 of 4 at 25%

Brett Ebert (2002) - TICK
Trent Burgoyne (2019) - (Still playing)
Jackson Mead (2019) - (Still playing)
Taj Schofield (2020) - (Still playing)

Richmond club banner

2 of 8 at 25%

Sean Bowden (1988)
Matthew Richardson (1992) - TICK
David Bourke (1994)
Joel Bowden (1995) - TICK
Nick Jewell (1995)
Tom Roach (2003)
Patrick Naish (2017) - (Still playing)

St Kilda club banner

0 of 3 at 0%

Stuart Annand (1989)
David Sierakowski (1992)
Bailey Rice (2015)

Sydney club banner

2 of 5 at 40%

Gareth John (1988)
Heath James (1998)
Stephen Doyle (1999)
Sean Dempster (2002) - TICK
Tom Mitchell (2011) - TICK - (Still playing at Hawthorn)

West Coast club banner

2 of 6 at 33.3%

Ashley McIntosh (1989) - TICK
Ben Cousins (1995) - TICK
Mitch Morton (2004)
Jacob Brennan (2010)
Alec Waterman (2014) - (Still playing at Essendon)
Jake Waterman (2016) - (Still playing)

Western Bulldogs banner

5 of 8 at 62.5%

Luke Darcy (1992) - TICK
David Round (1995)
Ayce Cordy (2008)
Tom Liberatore (2010) - TICK - (Still playing)
Mitch Wallis (2010) - TICK - (Still playing)
Lachie Hunter (2012) - TICK - (Still playing)
Zaine Cordy (2014) - TICK - (Still playing)
Rhylee West (2018) - (Still playing)

Note: Fitzroy were 1 from 1 with Jarrod Molloy rating as a TICK.

Adelaide Brisbane Lions Carlton Collingwood Essendon Fremantle Geelong Gold Coast Greater Western Sydney Hawthorn Melbourne North Melbourne Port Adelaide Richmond St Kilda Sydney Swans West Coast Eagles Western Bulldogs

More in AFL

Featured