By Gerard Whateley
Download the SEN App
Your Home of Sport, In your Hand
We go through fads with coaching… dictated largely by who is succeeding at any given time.
Change was the new religion… coaches win at the start of their tenure. If you’re not with the new wave thinking you’re camping out.
But there are international studies that conclude the single biggest. Determining factor in success is shared experience and coaching incumbency is a vital factor.
Our final four coaches have been in their jobs for a collective 48 seasons: Chris Fagan 8, Ken Hinkley 12, John Longmire and Chris Scott 14.
They have lived the various cycles. It’s not that long ago Scott was derided as home and away Chris… now he’s a coaching savant.
What all four have in common is the capacity to front up over and over again.
For Fagan and Hinkley this is preliminary final number four. For Brisbane it’s four in five years.
It started against Geelong at the Gabba in the COVID year and then two years later against the Cats at the MCG – both were heavy defeats.
Then last year the Lions absorbed the first five goals against before balancing up like a mature team to advance over Carlton.
It’s Geelong again on Saturday and the Lions are seasoned enough for the challenge.
Port Adelaide are 0-3 in Prelims under Ken. In his first season Ken Hinkley took his team to the MCG against the might of Hawthorn and ran them to three points in a desperate finish.
Six years later they made it back and stretched another dynasty team to a goal… falling to Richmond in a breathless climax. Both were full of merit.
The one that sticks in the craw is 2021. Port hosted the Bulldogs in the penultimate game and were shocking… conceding seven goals to one in an abject first term to lose by 71 points. That has sat heavily over club and coach since.
John Longmire has a great conversion rate – the Swans are 4-1 in his tenure in Preliminary Finals, while Chris Scott is 3-5 in the game regarded as the toughest to win.
After flying through his inaugural year, the Cats lost their next four Prelims in 2013, 2016, 2017 and 2019 including leading Hawthorn by 20 points at the final change and Richmond by 21 at the half.
They were held over Geelong, but are now a distant memory. The capacity to buck the system and contend endless while transitioning players and evolving style is now marveled at.
Shared experience and incumbency is in vogue this September. As is the varied ways to do the job from old school country coach through to tactical genius.