AFL

5 hours ago

Jenkins’ bold idea to improve AFL umpiring

By Andrew Slevison

Image
SEN Icon

Download the SEN App

Your Home of Sport, In your Hand

The quality of AFL umpiring has been questioned in recent times.

The best umpires in the league such as Brett Rosebury, Brendan Hosking, Nick Foot and Hayden Meyer - who officiated this year’s Grand Final - are seen as those at the very top of their game.

But there seemingly is a fair gap between the top and bottom umpires which frequently rankles the fans. This frustration has come to light since the introduction of four field umpires which has appeared to have shallowed, not deepened, the talent pool.

On SEN’s Summer Run, Sam Edmund discussed that lingering thought before Josh Jenkins floated a bold idea to improve the umpiring quality in the AFL.

“The officiating in the AFL was ‘a big deal’ this year. To borrow a phrase from Ron Burgundy, ‘a very big deal’,” Edmund said.

“The good umpires were very good, but then as was debated, the depth and the quality of our umpiring suffered at times as a result.”

Jenkins noted in the NFL this week that some referees are doubling up due to the grounding of flights in the USA.

It gave him an idea which potentially could be useful in the AFL.

“Something that happened because of the flight groundings in the States has has given me a bit of an idea,” said Jenkins.

“In the NFL, Don Willard, this guy ironically is actually a backup referee and not even one of the main referees. All referees across the NFL because of the flight issues were forced to only officiate the games within driving distance.

“So that was quite simple, but they were a little bit short on referees because of that fact. You couldn't get on a plane, you could only drive.

”Don Willard refereed the Indianapolis and Miami game, which only finished this morning. He would be in a vehicle right now driving to Cincinnati. It's about an 180-kilometre drive and he's going to referee Cincinnati versus Pittsburgh, which kicks off at about midday (AEDT).

“He's got three and a half hours to get to the stadium and get himself ready.”

149-gamer Jenkins understands it would be impossible for an AFL umpire to officiate two games in a day, but reckons two over the course of a round could be achievable for the very best match officials.

“Clearly you can't physically do that in the AFL,” he continued.

“Instead of exposing some of our umpires in the AFL that aren't quite ready, why aren't we just backing up and travelling our umpires more? Why aren't we having umpires, particularly in Melbourne, umpire a game say on a Thursday and then a Sunday? Or a Friday and a Sunday?

“Why aren't we having our best umpires umpire two games a weekend, and then having those umpires who are probably borderline as to whether they're good enough to do the job or not - and let's be honest, based on the way the game went this year and the way people felt about the umpiring - why not let those umpires get a game every two or three weeks and develop and grow without having to thrust them into the absolute spotlight of ‘get it done or else’ and potentially those umpires not being good enough.”

Physically, could umpires officiate two games in a weekend?

Edmund and Jenkins discussed if it would be possible.

Edmund: “Potentially the better whistleblowers in the AFL are being underused and could be utilised more.

“I can't think of an obvious reason as to why they wouldn't do that in the four umpire system.”

Jenkins: “One of the reasons they would suggest would probably be fatigue, having to back up. But they're not playing the game.”

Edmund: “Yeah, that would be (an issue) if you were doing three to four games a week in, but you could easily do two, couldn't you, if the games are spread from a Thursday to a Sunday?”

Jenkins: “And the running load with four (umpires) now has come down significantly, right? That's what they tell us.

“The physical load was way too much when there were three. Now there's four. It's a lot easier physically. So I don't see a reason why the best umpires wouldn't be umpiring a couple of games in a weekend, even if that meant a trip to Sydney or a trip to Adelaide.”

There were some instances in season 2026 where umpires did double up over a weekend, but doing it frequently could take its toll.

Umpire sources say the physical load isn't that much less with four umpires versus three. The volume is the same, but the intensity is down.

Umpires average 14km per game and some can officiate more than 25 matches in a season. That's getting up over eight marathons in a year.

They are also scrutinised more than ever before with decisions isolated on social media for all to see and assess in real time.

Listen to Jenkins' idea below:

AFL Teams