By Jaiden Sciberras
Presented by
Download the SEN App
Your Home of Sport, In your Hand
The 2021 draft is stacked with talent.
Featuring a Brownlow Medallist, six All-Australian blazers and a further five All-Australian 40-man nods, four best and fairest awards and SEVEN premierships, the '21 class has significantly over-achieved in their four seasons at AFL level.
But if the draft was selected today, would Jason Horne-Francis still go to North Melbourne with Pick 1?
We've gone back in time, re-drafting the class of 2021 based on the players we believe turned out best.
Pick 1 - Jason Horne-Francis (North Melbourne)
Pick 2 - Sam Darcy (Western Bulldogs)
Pick 3 - Finn Callaghan (GWS)
Pick 4 - Nick Daicos (Collingwood)
Pick 5 - Mac Andrew (Gold Coast)
Pick 6 - Josh Rachele (Adelaide)
Pick 7 - Josh Ward (Hawthorn)
Pick 8 - Jye Amiss (Fremantle)
Pick 9 - Josh Gibcus (Richmond)
Pick 10 - Neil Erasmus (Fremantle)
The original top 10 wasn't awful by any means. Horne-Francis entered the draft as the unanimous best non-club-tied talent, with Nick Daicos and Sam Darcy destined for the Pies and Dogs respectively.
Both of Fremantle's top 10 selections played in their 2026 Grand Final heartbreak, while the injury-riddled Josh Gibcus presents as the only player within the top 10 that is yet to play 50 AFL games.
However, if selectors had their time again... this is how we believe the top 10 would shape up.
Originally selected at Pick 4 by Collingwood
He was always going to the Pies - which is part of the reason he slipped to four - but Nick Daicos is the undisputed best player from the '21 crop.
Arguably the best player in the AFL, this one needs little explanation.
Originally selected at Pick 11 by St Kilda
The Roos went with powerful mid/forward Jason Horne-Francis with their original pick, but there was another South Australian talent that they could have gambled on instead.
St Kilda star Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera was originally selected with Pick 11, but would comfortably slide up to two if North Melbourne had their time again.
Hard to imagine where the Roos would be had Nas presented as a serious option on draft night.
Originally selected at Pick 2 by the Western Bulldogs
Like Daicos, Sam Darcy was destined for the Bulldogs, courtesy of father Luke.
If it weren't for two severe knee injuries in consecutive seasons, we could be talking about a multi-time Coleman Medallist, a multi-time All-Australian and the best forward - or better yet, best player - in our game.
Luck hasn't been on Darcy's side thus far, but don't let that distract you from the fact that Sam Darcy is a generational talent. For now, Pick 3 seems right.
Originally selected at Pick 1 by North Melbourne
After a messy exit from North Melbourne, Jason Horne-Francis has found himself at home at Port Adelaide.
Without Zak Butters, 2027 could be the year that Horne-Francis becomes the player he is poised to be. A hard-nosed bull in the contest with pace on the outside, there's little critique on what the SA star has accomplished thus far.
Winning his first best and fairest in 2026, JHF is just getting going, and while we have shifted him down three spots, it's hardly a knock on Horne-Francis himself given the talent that leads the line.
Originally selected at Pick 3 by GWS
Another exceptional talent that slips as a result of this year's absurd top-end.
Finn Callaghan has threatened to rise to superstardom for a number of years now, and while he's yet to truly establish himself as an out-and-out top-liner, it's really only a matter of time.
The Giants certainly won't regret their original selection, and up to this point, there's very little separating Callaghan and JHF.
Originally selected at Pick 8 by Fremantle
It took a year or two longer than many expected, but Jye Amiss proved himself as one of the game's premier key forwards in 2026.
His second season in purple was exceptional for a young key, booting 41 goals and locking up a spot as a regular in Fremantle's front half.
And while his next two seasons were plagued by statistical regression, 61 goals, fifth place in the Coleman Medal race and the leading goalkicker on a Grand Final side alongside Josh Treacy and Patrick Voss in 2026 was just the season Amiss needed to reclaim his status.
A hit from the Dockers.
Originally selected at Pick 5 by Gold Coast
A key position talent that has far more promise than has been delivered thus far, Mac Andrew continues to border on stardom.
Re-committing to the Suns on a monster contract, Andrew hasn't quite lived up to the price tag. That said, with his elite length, high-level intercepting and athletic prowess, he remains a talent on the verge of explosion.
Once again, the Suns won't regret this pick - clearly the best key defender in the class and one of the game's most promising backmen.
Originally selected at Pick 20 by Brisbane
The first player originally selected outside the top 10, Brisbane's steal with Pick 20 has played a major role in their historical three-peat.
Playing 72 games over the last three seasons, Lohmann has booted 111 goals, delivering eight of those within the club's three straight Grand Final wins.
Only getting better year-on-year, Lohmann's ceiling remains undefined. An exceptional pick by the Lions.
Originally selected at Pick 6 by Adelaide
Josh Rachele's career thus far has been a series of almosts... but it's sure to break open at some stage.
Caught between roles, Rachele's best position remains unidentified at the Crows. Stints in the middle have shown promise but have never lasted, and while his forward craft is top-line, he is yet to shake the tendency to go missing when the occasion calls.
Committing his full focus to the front half from 2027 and beyond, the best of Rachele is likely to be on full display in the coming seasons.
Originally selected at Pick 16 by Brisbane
Yet another crucial piece in Brisbane's threepeat, Wilmot earns the final spot in the top 10 re-draft thanks to his immense influence on winning.
Incredibly, Darcy Wilmot has not missed a single game for Brisbane over the last four seasons, playing in every home and away game and every final including all four Grand Finals.
He's won over 70 per cent of those games, averaging in and around the 20-disposal mark and delivering in all of the Lions' three premiership wins.
The 2021 class runs deep, meaning there are a number of talents that miss out on the top 10 but deserve recognition.
Josh Ward and Neil Erasmus were both selected within the top 10 and have both held up their end of the bargain, developing into great AFL players after cementing their places at Hawthorn and Fremantle respectively.
Paul Curtis, Jacob van Rooyen, Connor Macdonald and Mitch Owens are all highly talented forward-half players, all established first-team players who have the potential to explode in the coming seasons.
Matt Roberts, Jake Soligo, Marcus Windhager and Jase Burgoyne also deserve mention.
The next superstars of the competition are just days away, with the 2026 AFL National Draft kicking off on Thursday, November 19th at 7:00pm AEDT.