By SEN
Download the SEN App
Your Home of Sport, In your Hand
Robert ‘Crash’ Craddock has attempted to make sense of the current state of Sandpapergate.
After listening closely to Gerard Whateley’s interview with Chadd Sayers on SEN Cricket on Sunday, Craddock had more to say.
He insists he is not picking sides, but was intrigued to hear what Sayers had to say given he has “no skin in the game”.
“At the moment I’m not on any side in particular. I’m listening to all the evidence,” he said on SEN Mornings.
“But I will say is - I found Chadd Sayers very, very believable. He’s been my barometer in this.
“Sayers has no skin in the game. He's just a really uncomplicated, decent fellow who doesn't like controversy.
“He's never been involved in anything really controversial. He likes Khawaja and he likes Cummins. So I was all ears yesterday and I really liked his evidence.
“He just seemed to speak from the heart. It just sounded believable. So I'll be honest with you, since our Sandpapergate investigation a few months ago, and the other journalists doing it found out that the sandpaper was used in two Tests, I found it extremely hard to believe that the bowlers did not know.
“Because bowlers talk, and there's one last little story I'll tell you, and I should have brought this up much earlier in the recent weeks. Here's another factor, before 2018, the use of doctoring a cricket ball was not considered a heinous offence, so no one really kept it secret.
“It'd be like your boss at work challenging you for claiming extra on your expenses. It was that sort of offence where it wasn't like players taking money from Indian bookmakers, which was heinous and kept really quiet.
“It was a bit of a joke. Faf Du Plessis, who was charged with using a mint in Perth, arrived in Adelaide, was going down the escalators and poked his tongue at reporters and he had a mint on his tongue. So in other words, what I'm saying is, there was no pressure to keep it secret and that's why I thought that to using it in two Tests that the word would just get around, wouldn't it? Or am I being too simplistic about it?”
“Pat Cummins, I was staggered how strong he was. I really was. Pat is a naturally diffident sort of guy.
“If he was in your studio and you gave him a coffee, he'd say, ‘Yeah, it's nice coffee, mate’. And a good day outside, ‘Yeah, it is, isn't it?’
“He rolls along with arguments. And I think with his wife Becky in that video - and he said that conversation was about Usman - it looked as if she was sort of saying, ‘Pat, you've got to go strong here’.
“So it was of Churchillian strength.
“But, I’m not ready to declare that is the end of the argument. Many of my mates are, and I've had texts saying, ‘Oh, Pat's put Usman in his place and everything like that and blah, blah, blah’. He did win a couple of arguments, he did. Like he said, ‘Hey Usman, if you felt that strongly about it when you saw the sandpaper and you were counselling Bancroft about be careful here, why didn't you stop it?’ Totally fair point. Totally fair point.
“Some would have, you know, some would have said, ‘Mate, this is outrageous. Do not do it’. But he didn't. And he puts his hand up for that, Khawaja.
“But all of that really is irrelevant. It's simply a matter of did they know or didn't they know? And I have to say when Chadd Sayers admitted to going out and fetching the sandpaper at drinks from Bancroft and taking it back. Man, oh man.
“It is a stretch to think that from that situation, other bowlers in the team and the coaches didn't know what was happening. But here's the thing, there is no evidence, there is no smoking gun, there is no email, there is no text message, there's no evidence at all and that makes it hard.
“It's just one man's opinion versus the other. And there's no killer anecdote either. No one has said these words, ‘Oh, so anyway, we had a meeting and all of us were sitting around and they produced the sandpaper and all 16 of us were looking at it’. In terms of ‘this is the plan’.
“So until such times as someone provides the killer anecdote… I deeply suspected everyone knows, but I can't prove it, if you know what I mean.”
“He’s gone out on a ledge, he really has.
“He may know too that there's no evidence, there's no text, there's no smoking gun, there's no game plan, so it's one man's view.
“I’ve always been worried about the bowlers, since that time Cameron Bancroft said it was self-explanatory that they knew. And then they released a statement the next day, which was very categorical. ‘We did not know about sandpaper that day’.
“‘That day’. Well, I know I've heard people say who are close to David Warner that he said, ‘I could have produced that statement because I didn't know about that on that day either’.
“So there was a feeling that that statement was a little bit Bill Clinton when he was allegedly smoking marijuana and said, ‘I didn't inhale’. You know that selective truth that keeps you within the bounds?
“I’ll never forget Hansie Cronje, the great match-fixer from South Africa. I went to his press conference in South Africa when he denied it. And he said, ‘I want to say categorically, I did not take money from bookmakers in South Africa’. But you know why he got away with that? Because you took it from bookmakers in India.
“So you've got to be careful.
“Here's the thing, now Pat was much more categorical on Friday, wasn't he? He blasted a lot of things out of the water, and he went in as hard as he ever has in his life, probably, and will never do again. He will never comment on this issue again, he reckons.
“But for me, the door is still open.”
“When Gerard did his excellent, excellent interview with Chadd Sayers yesterday, which was so good, we're having a class for cadets on Wednesday, and we're going to play them that interview.
“It's just a subtle way of asking hard questions in a sort of a delicate manner. I was all ears because Chad is my barometer man in this. He was there. He was in the middle of it. He was on neither side. He likes Khawaja. He likes Cummins. And he hates controversy.
“I understand by the end of play yesterday when he commentated for SEN that he was just a bit taught by it, he's not used to that. So here's the question. Why would he lie? You tell me. Why would he lie?"
“Pat Cummins is a loveable sort of guy. He's a really decent human being. Nothing in his argument changes this no matter whether you believe him or you don't.
“The same with Mitch Starc and Josh Hazlewood and that. And on the other side of the argument, you know, there are people who love bagging David Warner and Usman Khawaja. So sometimes the villains can be right and the heroes can be wrong. It's a very, very vexed question.
“We’re fighting at the paper here. One of our editors just came past me about 10 minutes ago and he said, ‘The stories that people still love in the media are those where the truth is hard to find and you're not sure who the villain and hero is’.
“And I said, ‘I’m still trying to find it after eight years. What sort of a gibberer am I?’."
“I think it really kills cricket Australia. They haven't got a test this week. A Test will wash it away. There's no doubt about it, but they've got this vacuous One-Day series against England which care-factor there is very, very low.
“So it is dominating the headlines. It's just that solitary thought that I keep coming back to that before 2018, you could tamper with the ball and tell the guy next to you in the dressing room, he couldn't care. It was not a trade secret that it is now.
“That's partially the reason why I suspected that the chain of knowledge was very wide, very wide.”