Horse Racing

1 hour ago

“Frustrated, angry, sad”: Gareth Hall's impassioned So You Are plea

By SEN

Image
SEN Icon

Download the SEN App

Your Home of Sport, In your Hand

Gareth Hall kicked off today's Giddy Up with an impassioned statement surrounding the horrific vision of So You Are being found in a skip bin this week.

Read the statement below:

I start Giddy Up this morning with a mixture of emotions… and I imagine many of you are feeling exactly the same way.

I’m frustrated, I’m angry, but above all, I’m incredibly sad.

Sad that any horse, let alone a mighty warrior like So You Are, could end up in a skip bin in Southern Sydney just two weeks after competing in the Melbourne Cup.

And sad that an industry I love is once again under attack, and for all the wrong reasons.

When I first saw that video, I honestly couldn’t believe what I was looking at.

That sickening feeling in my stomach will stay with me for a long time.

I sat there in shock, trying to comprehend how on earth this could have happened.

On Monday, I understood that everything possible had been done to save So You Are’s life.

He was at one of Australia’s best agistment properties when he suffered a severe bout of colic. He was then rushed to Randwick Equine Centre, one of the world’s leading equine veterinary hospitals, where he received the very best possible care.

No expense was spared. The veterinary team did everything they could to save him and that’s important to acknowledge.

Horses die from colic. It’s heart-breaking and devastating, but sadly, it’s a reality of the industry we work in.

What we cannot accept is what happened afterwards.

So You Are was taken to Cleanaway’s Lucas Heights facility and, in the most basic terms, was treated without the respect he deserved.

The contractor transporting him couldn’t access the required unloading area with the truck, and his body was subsequently transferred into a skip bin.

And perhaps even more concerning is the suggestion that this is common practice.

Racing NSW released a statement saying:

“These images are distressing for all involved and for all of us who care deeply about our horses.”

They went on to say: “The way in which So You Are’s body was left is distressing and completely unacceptable.

Racing NSW explained that So You Are had been transported for burial and was being held temporarily while awaiting that burial.

They also referenced NSW Department of Primary Industries guidelines, which identify licensed landfill as the preferred option for animals euthanised using certain chemicals.

However, they acknowledged that burial should have occurred in a timely and respectful manner.

Randwick Equine Centre’s managing partner, Jonathan Lumsden, took full responsibility.

He acknowledged that while the centre did not carry out the burial itself, it selected the provider and made the arrangements.

He admitted the process was not good enough.

The centre has since stopped using that service provider and is reviewing its arrangements to ensure this never happens again.

You also have to spare a thought for Bjorn Baker, his team and the Ramsey family.

They have lost a horse they loved and cared for, and they have had to deal with the added distress of seeing these images.

Now, this is a complex issue.

The contractors involved may not have broken any laws. But that doesn’t mean the practices are acceptable, and it certainly doesn’t mean we shouldn’t demand better.

Society expects better standards. The racing industry must expect better standards of itself.

And there is a model we should be looking at.

New Zealand has taken a proactive approach, establishing dedicated equine crematorium facilities, supported by the racing industry through its welfare funding.

There is a facility in the Waikato servicing the North Island and another in Canterbury servicing the South Island.

They also have specialist horse collection and transport services to ensure horses can be handled appropriately after death.

Why can’t we investigate a similar model here in Australia?

Why can’t our industry develop a dedicated, transparent and dignified process for the final journey of our horses?

This isn’t about pointing fingers for the sake of it. It’s about making sure something like this never happens again.

The responsibility of caring for a racehorse doesn’t end when its racing career finishes. And it certainly doesn’t end when that horse takes its final breath.

Make no mistake, it was an ugly and sad day for our industry yesterday.

Racing participants, racing fans and, most importantly, our equine heroes deserve better.

Racing is full of wonderful people who love their animals. We see that every day, and we should be proud of the industry we are part of.

The facts are that So You Are was loved and cared for from the day he was born until his final day.

The way he was treated after his death was the complete opposite.

I have no doubt we will learn from yesterday and we will get better.

Racing leaders face many challenges, but horse welfare and our social licence to operate remain our greatest responsibilities.

And yesterday was a very sad reminder of that.


The body of So You Are was found in a Sydney skip bin just weeks after finishing eighth in this year's Melbourne Cup.

The five-year-old gelding, trained by Bjorn Baker, was pronounced dead on Monday, having battled a severe bout of colic. Just a day later, the horse's remains were discovered within a skip bin by Sydney resident Gregg Jowett.

Baker released a statement following the revelation, requesting a prompt explanation from veterinary service REC Equine Specialists, of whom the horse's care was placed prior to his death.

"Like everyone who has seen the footage, I am deeply distressed by the handling of So You Are's remains," Baker said.

"He was a much-loved horse, and he deserves to be treated with respect and dignity after his death.

"I understand the specialist hospital facility REC Equine Specialists are investigating the circumstances, and I expect a full explanation of what occurred.

"My thoughts remain with the Ramsey family [owners], and with all my staff, for whom this has compounded an already devastating loss."

REC Equine Specialists has spoken out on the incident.

"After his death, So You Are was collected by our contracted service provider and taken to a licensed landfill. He should have been promptly and respectfully buried," they said.

"What happened was unacceptable and disrespectful to So You Are and to everyone else who cared for him. We are deeply sorry.

"So You Are was in our care. We did not carry out the burial ourselves, but we chose the provider and the arrangements, and we take full responsibility for that.

"We should have known exactly how horses were handled after leaving our hospital, and we did not. That process is not good enough, and it must change.

"We have spoken with So You Are's owners and trainer to apologise personally. We are working with our service provider and the facility operators, together with Racing NSW, to establish how this happened and to put in processes to ensure it never happens again."

The findings will be shared with Racing NSW.

So You Are produced a successful spring with four straight wins, including the Bendigo Cup, on the way to the Melbourne Cup.

He won eight races and tallied over $1.4 million in prize money in his 29-start career.