AFL

3 hours ago

Draft gems: Your club's best value selections

By SEN

Image
SEN Icon

Download the SEN App

Your Home of Sport, In your Hand

Who have been the best value picks in the history of the National Draft?

SEN’s Julian De Stoop undertook the task of compiling each of the 18 clubs and their best selections beyond Pick 35 with help from the SEN listeners, callers and texters.

There are strict rules for this: No father/sons, no rookies, no pre-season draftees, no mid-season draftees and they have to have been drafted by your club.

This is inspired by Sam Mitchell being taken by Hawthorn with Pick 36 in the 2001 Superdraft.

See each club’s Top 3 value picks below:

ADELAIDE club banner

Graham Johncock (Pick 67,2000) - 227 games and 120 goals

David Mackay (Pick 48, 2006) - 248 games and 68 goals

Rory Sloane (Pick 44, 2008) - 255 games, 136 goals, 2xB&F, 1xAA, Captain

Taylor Walker (Pick 75) ineligible as he was signed by the Crows in 2006 under the AFL's NSW Scholarship Scheme.

Brisbane club banner

Daniel Bradshaw (Pick 56, 1995) - 222 games and 496 goals, 2xpremierships

Joel Patfull (Pick 56, 2005) - 182 games, 26 goals, 2xB&F

Oscar McInerney (Pick 37, 2016) - 165 games, 67 goals, 1xpremiership

Harris Andrews (Pick 61) ineligible as he was a Queensland zone selection.

Carlton club banner

Michael Sexton (Pick 54, 1988) - 200 games, 23 goals, 2xAA, 1xpremiership

Brendan Fevola (Pick 38, 1998) - 187 games, 575 goals, 3xAA, 2xColeman

Kade Simpson (Pick 45, 2002) - 342 games, 139 goals, 1xB&F

Collingwood club banner

Paul Williams (Pick 70, 1989) - 189 games, 223 goals

Scott Burns (Pick 90, 1992) - 265 games, 149 goals, captain

Dane Swan (Pick 58, 2001) - 258 games, 211 goals, 1xBrownlow, 1xpremiership, 5xAA, 3xB&F, 1xMVP

Essendon club banner

James Hird (Pick 79, 1990) - 253 games 343 goals, 2xpremierships, 1xBrownlow, 1xNorm Smith, 5xAA, 5xB&F

Damien Hardwick (Pick 87, 1992) - 153 games, 13 goals, 1xpremiership, 1xAA, 1xB&F

Cale Hooker (Pick 54, 2007) - 219 games, 122 goals, 1xB&F, 1xAA

Fremantle club banner

Michael Walters (Pick 53, 2008) - 239 games, 365 goals, 1xAA

Lachie Neale (Pick 58, 2011) - 135 games, 67 goals, 2xB&F

Luke Ryan (Pick 66, 2016) - 205 games, 2xAA, 1xB&F

Geelong club banner

Cameron Ling (Pick 38, 19992) - 246 games, 139 goals, 3xpremierships, 1xAA, 1xB&F, captain

Corey Enright (Pick 47, 1999) - 332 games, 67 goals, 3xpremierships, 6xAA, 2xB&F

Tom Stewart (Pick 40, 2016) - 214 games, 5xAA, 1xpremiership, 2xB&F

GOLD COAST club banner

Charlie Ballard (Pick 42, 2017) - 145 games

Jy Farrar (Pick 60, 2019) - 45 games, 14 goals

Caleb Graham (Pick 71, 2018) - 37 games

GWS Giants club banner

Connor Idun (Pick 61, 2018) - 140 games

Jake Riccardi (Pick 51, 2019) - 98 games, 124 goals

Harvey Thomas (Pick 59, 2023) - 62 games, 27 goals

Hawthorn club banner

Sam Mitchell (Pick 36, 2001) - 307 games, 67 goals, 4xpremierships, 5xB&F, 3xAA, 1xBrownlow, premiership captain

James Sicily (Pick 56, 2013) - 203 games, 78 goals, captain, 1xAA, 1xB&F

Blake Hardwick (Pick 44, 2015) - 223 games, 41 goals

Melbourne club banner

Stephen Tingay (Pick 50, 1987) - 162 games, 84 goals, 1xAA

Russell Robertson (Pick 68, 1996) - 228 games, 428 goals, 1xB&F

Cameron Bruce (Pick 64, 1999) - 234 games, 211 goals, 1xB&F

North Melbourne club banner

Brent Harvey (Pick 47, 1995) - 432 games, 518 goals, 1xpremiership, 4xAA, 5xB&F, Captain

David King (Pick 46, 1993) - 241 games, 145 goals, 2xpremiership, 2xAA

Todd Goldstein (Pick 37, 2006) - 315 games 157 goals, 1xAA, 1xB&F

Port Adelaide club banner

Robbie Gray (Pick 55, 2006) - 271 games, 367 goals, 4xAA, 4xB&F

Justin Westhoff (Pick 71, 2006) - 280 games, 313 goals, 1xB&F

Dom Cassisi (Pick 50, 2000) - 228 games, 74 goals, 1xpremiership, Captain

Richmond club banner

Nick Daffy (Pick 49, 1990) - 165 games, 181 goals, 1xB&F

Matthew Rogers (Pick 37, 1992) - 197 games, 163 goals

Chris Newman (Pick 55, 2000) - 268 games, 56 goals, Captain

ST KILDA club banner

Leigh Montagna (Pick 37, 2001) - 287 games, 155 goals, 2xAA

Sam Fisher (Pick 55, 2003) - 228 games, 22 goals, 2xB&F, 1xAA

Jack Steven (Pick 42, 2007) - 192 games, 113 goals, 4xB&F

Sydney Swans club banner

Adam Goodes (Pick 43, 1997) - 372 games, 464 goals, 1xpremiership, 2xBrownlow, 4xAA, 3xB&F, Rising Star, Captain

Michael O’Loughlin (Pick 40, 1994) - 303 games, 521 goals, 1xpremiership, 2xAA, 1xB&F

Luke Parker (Pick 40, 293 games) - 213 goals, 1xpremiership, 3xB&F, 1xAA, Captain

West Coast club banner

Dean Kemp (Pick 119, 1989) - 243 games, 117 goals, 2xpremierships, 1xNorm Smith, 1xAA, 1xB&F

Brett Heady (Pick 92, 1989) - 156 games, 237 goals, 2xpremierships

Andrew Embley (Pick 57, 1998) - 250 games, 216 goals, 1xpremiership, 1xNorm Smith

Western Bulldogs club banner

Chris Grant (Pick 105, 1988) - 341 games, 554 goals, 3xAA, 2xB&F

Brian Lake (Pick 71, 2001) - 197 games, 32 goals, 2xAA, 1xB&F

Easton Wood (Pick 43, 2007) - 188 games, 20 goals, premiership captain, 1xAA, 1xB&F

AFL Teams